For the longest time, one of the most sustained cultural wars between the British and Americans is over the pronunciation of certain words and their spellings. Now an X post has once again ignited this long-standing debate over the “correct” or “superior” pronunciation of certain words. On Monday, an X user posted, “Just discovered how Americans pronounce niche, need a moment.” This post soon went viral with 29.9 million views. Many British pronounce niche as “neesh”, which rhymes with sheesh, whereas the Americans pronounce it as “nich”, which rhymes with pitch.
just discovered how americans pronounce niche, need a moment— Emma Loffhagen (@emmaloffhagen) June 3, 2024
This X post prompted Americans and Brits to go after each other about the pronunciation of different words.
An X user wrote, “Almost as disturbing as how Americans say “sodder” instead of “solder”.”
https://twitter.com/littleblue_dino/status/1797888872333955567
A US citizen struck back and wrote, “I felt the same way when I discovered Brits use an “s” instead of a “z”, such as recognise, even though the spelling is “recognize” in the Oxford, Cambridge, and Webster dictionary. I’m still not over it.”
I felt the same way when I discovered Brits use an “s” instead of a “z”, such as recognise, even though the spelling is “recognize” in the Oxford, Cambridge, and Webster dictionary. I’m still not over it.— PC Trades (@PhiNanceToday) June 4, 2024
Another US citizen wrote back, “Americans do not speak the Queen’s English. People who call cigarettes “fags”, erasers “rubbers”, and fries “chips” have no place criticizing the languages used by other cultures, even if it is “English”. And yes, America has a completely different culture than Britain does.”
Americans do not speak the Queen's English. People who call cigarettes "fags", erasers "rubbers", and fries "chips" have no place critizing the languages used by other cultures, even if it is "English". And yes, America has a completely different culture than Brittain does.— DJ White (@dwhite0279) June 4, 2024
Some people also pointed out many Americans also say “neesh” just as the British. Making this point, an X user wrote, “I pronounce it “neesh” — I think it’s a regional thing in America too cause I’ve never heard it said the other way except for on a British podcast where they said Americans pronounce it that way.” Adding to it, someone else wrote, “I think it is a regional thing too. America is not one size fits all, much more regional variability in how things are pronounced compared to the UK. While I do say “nitch,” I’m from hillbilly country.”
I think it is a regional thing too. America is not once size fits all, much more region variability in how things are pronounced compared to the UK. While I do say “nitch,” I’m from hillbilly country.— H S (@shellyonen) June 5, 2024
Merriam-Webster dictionary also joined the debate. In a series of posts, Merriam-Webster dictionary wrote that “nich”, which rhymes with pitch, is the “more common one and the older of the two pronunciations.”
NEESH wasn’t listed as a pronunciation in our dictionaries until our 1961 Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, Unabridged, and it wasn’t entered into our smaller Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary until 1993.— Merriam-Webster (@MerriamWebster) June 4, 2024
It further added that the “neesh”, rhyming with sheesh, was not listed as a pronunciation until the 1961 Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, Unabridged. Additionally, it was not added into the smaller Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary until 1993.
According to the Oxford dictionary, niche means “a comfortable or suitable position in life or employment” or a “specialised segment of the market for a particular kind of product or service”.